Learn ›
Learn · FundamentalsAre Cigar of the Month Clubs Worth It?
A cigar club is paying someone else to build your sampler every month... whether that's worth it depends on how much the curation is worth to you, because it rarely wins on price alone.
What clubs actually cost
The mainstream clubs run roughly $30 to $45 a month for four or five cigars, which works out to $7 to $9 a stick... about street price for a solid everyday premium. Boutique and "luxury" tiers climb to $75 or beyond for rarer picks. Shipping is sometimes included and sometimes the quiet extra dollar per cigar, so read the checkout page, not the banner.
The "retail value" trick
Every club advertises the same hook: cigars "valued at" some number comfortably above what you paid. That valuation is MSRP, and MSRP is the price almost nobody pays. Judge the same five cigars at street price... what they'd cost from a normal online retailer on a normal day... and the advertised gap shrinks, sometimes to nothing. The club isn't lying, exactly. It's just measuring its generosity with the most flattering ruler available.
What you're really buying
Curation, and it's worth something. A decent club hands a new smoker a guided tour: different wrappers, sizes, and strengths chosen by someone who's smoked wider than they have, plus tasting notes to smoke against. That solves a real beginner problem... standing in front of a thousand SKUs with no map (how to buy cigars). It also makes one of the few genuinely good cigar gifts, since it ships itself and requires no knowledge from the giver.
Where the math breaks
The curation cuts both ways: no control over strength, size, or profile, so the month your shipment runs full-strength boxy gordos is the month you own five of them. Some clubs pad shipments with house brands and closeout stock that would cost far less bought directly. Cigars arrive as mail travelers and want a rest before judging. And subscriptions auto-renew, which is how a three-month experiment becomes a year of paying street price for someone else's taste.
The self-built alternative
Online sampler packs do the same discovery job for less. The permanent sale culture means a five-cigar sampler of known lines routinely undercuts a club month (when a sale changes the math), you pick the direction... all maduro, all mild, all one size... and there's no recurring charge waiting for you to forget it. A beginner kit plus two or three cheap samplers is a better first hundred dollars than four club months.
The call
As a gift, or as first-year tuition for someone who wants variety without homework: reasonable. As a long-term way to buy cigars once you know your own palate: weak, because you'll outgrow the curation and keep paying for it. The one version worth the money is the high-end, short-member-list club built around genuinely hard-to-find limited releases... and only if that hunt is the part you enjoy.
Keep reading
From the humidor I'm not in any of these, and I don't plan to be. Two things sell a club: it puts cigars in your hands you wouldn't have picked yourself, or it gets you limited stuff you can't find anywhere else. The first one I'd rather solve at a shop. I've got a couple of tobacconists who have watched me smoke for a while now... they know what I've liked and what I haven't, and they'll point me at something new that fits better than a bin some company filled with whatever they needed to move. And I already have more cigars I want to try than I have evenings to try them. The second one, the high-end clubs with a short member list and genuinely hard-to-find sticks, I can see the appeal... it's just not for me. I don't chase limited editions: I don't want to fall for one and never get another, and I really don't want to save one for a special night and have it stink. So for me it's a no. If getting surprised every month is the fun part for you, go for it... that's just not what I'm buying cigars for.